Critique Service

I’ve been spinning tales for over two decades, collaborating with boutique and top-tier national publishers, and critiquing hundreds of manuscripts for others. Currently, I am all geared up to review your picture or board book manuscript. Take a peek at the downloadable flyer below for all the details. Keep scrolling for testimonials and payment options. Please contact me if you have any questions.

Promotional image for Danna Smith's manuscript critique service, outlining four steps to enhance a manuscript, including contact details, services, and feedback timeline.

DOWNLOAD FLYER

What writers are saying (I’m blushing!)

Super Helpful!

It was like having a mini-personal class on picture book writing. —Jonelle S.

I’m Dazzled!

I am dazzled by Danna’s work ethic. She is a relentless reviser! And her persistence pays off — with a shelf full of books to her credit. I wouldn’t submit a manuscript without her excellent feedback, and you shouldn’t either. —Carolyn Fisher, author-illustrator of Cells: An Owner’s Handbook

Like Chatting with a Good Friend

While the majority of the kidlit community is kind and helpful, I feel like Danna epitomizes what the community is all about. She is definitely quick and thorough, but working with Danna feels like you’re sitting and chatting with a good friend, finding the emotional heart of a story as a conversation. It’s not every critiquer that can pull that off, and she will definitely help your stories shine!  —Eileen Manes.

A Master Critiquer

Danna is a master critique-er. She has given me feedback on my picture book manuscripts for over 20 years, and I completely trust her ability to zero in on what works and what doesn’t. —Sharlee Glenn

From Draft to Publication

Danna has critiqued my manuscripts for many years,  and I trust her feedback.  With her insight and inspiration, I’ve been able to take many stories from first draft to publication. She’s one of the best in the business,  and I highly recommend her to any hopeful writer.  — Kristyn Crow,  Author of ALL ABOARD THE MOONLIGHT TRAIN and the ZOMBELINA Series

Insightful and Useful Feedback

Danna has always given me insightful and useful feedback, looking not only at things like story structure and wording, but also at how readers are likely to respond to my work. She is tuned in to the market, as well, which is impressive considering how much it shifts around! —Kate Combs, author of Little Naturalist and Little Poet board book series

I Love Working with Danna

Simply put, working with Danna has made me a better picture book author! She improves each manuscript with clear, insightful, and always respectful feedback. I always run my work by Danna before I submit it. You can trust Danna, a highly successful author with incredible wisdom to impart, and she does so with grace and amazing efficiency. —Deborah Miller

Kind Yet Honest

With her experience as a prolific published children’s author, Danna Smith provides kind, yet honest and invaluable critiques that can significantly improve any story. —Ken Baker

Feeling More Confident

Thank you so much for the time you put into your critique. I greatly appreciate it and found it extremely helpful. I feel more confident rewriting and editing now that I have a clear idea of how to improve my work.—Korrie H.

Aware of Market Needs

Danna has a way of honing in on exactly the right elements when it comes to giving a critique. She is both astute with revision suggestions and aware of market needs and trends. She is a rhyming genius and can help take any picture book text to the next level. —Lezlie Evans

Quick and Insightful

I have been in a children’s book critique group with Danna Smith for several years. She is an inspiration. She is quick to praise strengths and insightful in offering room for improvement. She is among the most prolific children’s book writers I know. She is brave and courageous – willing to revise and try different topics, writing styles, and settings to find the best fit for her ideas. She’s a gem. —Linda Kimball

Purchase a Critique